determining the relative seniority between DRs & DPs because the issue of relative seniority has been finally decided by the CAT on 20th November ... finding recorded by the CAT in matter. The only issue addressed by the CAT was preparation of seniority list in the grade of Assistant Civilian
common order dated 12.1.2004. In its determination the CAT, Ahmedabad
held, that seniority of direct recruits would have to be determined with
reference ... Tribunal, Jodhpur Bench, Jodhpur (hereinafter referred to as “the CAT,
Jodhpur”), to assail the seniority-list wherein direct recruit Income Tax
Inspectors, though appointed later
former plea and directed the
determination of the seniority of the employees of the CAT from the date of
their deputation. Such directions were issued ... CAT from a date even prior to the inception of CAT on
1.11.1985; or two sets of principles for determination of seniority one
laid down
basis of the interpretation of the said Rules, the
CAT had fixed the seniority of DR and DP ACSOs based on the
length of continuous ... situation
had occurred due to the assignment of antedated seniority,
i.e., giving seniority from the date of occurrence of vacancy to
DR ACSOs
CAT?
32. We have quoted the order of the CAT hereinabove and
what the CAT ordered was that the IREM determining the
inter se seniority ... been noted
by the CAT and yet the CAT did not discuss this judgment.
It is obvious that the CAT did not go into
unfilled
vacancies".
Findings and Observations of CAT
14. The CAT, based on its appreciation of the submissions of the parties
and the materials placed ... guise
of loss of seniority could not have been entertained and adjudicated upon by
the CAT.
W.P.(C) 209/2013 Page
employees; it was allowed
on 05.07.1988 (hereafter “CAT 1988 order”). CAT directed the department to
recast seniority in accordance with the 1986 OM after giving ... issued. DRIs, whose seniority was affected
by the revised seniority list filed review applications6 in the disposed of
applications. The CAT reiterated its main order
through the CAT (Ahmedabad Bench) file No. 1/41/Estt./CAT/ A 'bad/97, Vol.II and l/42/Estt./CAT ... Date of Joining the CAT
Date of Absorption/Regular Promotion in Grade of UDC in CAT
Positionin Draft Seniority list
Position in Seniority liston
Checkers instituted O.A. No. 105 of 2011 before the CAT to
question the seniority list/order dated 22nd January 2011.
10] However, the CAT ... promotion order dated 3rd February 2005, the
seniority list existing on record was the seniority list dated
25th January 2005. The respondents, i.e., Union
rules, it has to be counted towards seniority.
27. In the matter of seniority if a final seniority is not challenged, it cannot be corrected ... inter-se-seniority where one set of employees claim their seniority from the date of their deputation to the service of the CAT
