directed the prosecution to supply to the accused a
complete transcript conversation of CD handed over by the Investigating
Officer, vide detailed order dated ... list, the CD in dispute i.e. the CD handed over by the complainant is mentioned
at Sr.No.6. This CD is also
also added by Ld. Defence Counsel that the content of
the CD and Transcription of Video Recording concerning the incident
of 12.09.2008 and 16.09.2008 cannot ... submitted by Ld.
Defence Counsel that the content of the CD and Transcription of
Video Recording concerning the incident of 12.09.2008 and
16.09.2008 cannot
bears
my signature at point B. Memo of transcription of CD
copy A, Ex.PW11/A bears my signature at points ... Page No. 28 of 29
Naresh Kumar and preparation of the Transcription of CD by the IO
on 13.02.2008 and specifically keeping in mind that
Thereafter, on 20.04.2011, IO took into
possession another CD alongwith its transcript from Shri H.K Juneja,
Ld.Dy.RegistarcumPrincipal Secretary ... sought a second opinion on the
said CD from CFSL, Chandigarh. Accordingly, the CD alongwith its
transcript was sent to CFSL, Chandigarh
identified
the voice of the accused in the same. The transcript of the CD Mark
Q1 (Ex.P4) was proved ... identified by
PW6 and IO PW8 Inspector Manas Dey. The transcript of the CD
Q2 Ex.PW4/D2 and perusal whereof shows
Devi Singh
pullanda, containing CD, has been proved as Ex. PW 4/P.
The said CD, used for transferring the conversation is
proved ... been proved as Ex. PW 4/T and the
transcription of conversation of another CD is proved as
Ex. PW 4/U. The voice identification
CD of the chip was never deposited in Malkhana and even
PW9 could not state as to when the CD was received and the
transcript ... conversation of negotiation on his mobile and
sent one CD alongwith his Complaint but said CD has not been
produced and same is fatal
CD and
since PW4/complainant denied to have given any such CD to the
police officials, the FSL Report can be of no help ... have stated to
the police that a Transcript had been prepared with the help of CD
which was handed over to police officials of Anti
also deposed about sending the
questioned CDs with specimen CD to CFSL vide forwarding letter
Ex.PW11/E. He further deposed about obtaining ... accused allegedly communicated the
complainant. He further deposed about preparing the transcript
Ex.PW3/G and Ex.PW3/M besides preparing the transcription
complaint were down
loaded on to the computer and a new compact CD was prepared. The
proceedings were recorded and recorder observation memo ... record, got recorded the
specimen voice of the complainant and also the transcription of conversation
recorded between accused persons and the complainant
