records in Para 9 "that the said washes were sent to CFSL
for opinion of the expert vide letter No. 3220 dated ... authority had
considered the material placed before it, it had considered the CFSL
report mentioned in Para 9, which obviously is not the CFSL report
same were seized.
6. Subsequently, during investigation, the washes were referred to CFSL
for chemical examination and the CFSL expert vide his report ... Amar Singh Rawat and complainant (PW-3) were sent to
CFSL for comparison with the specimen voice samples. CFSL confirmed
the similarity of questioned voice
proceedings and at the time when the trap was executed;
(vi). the CFSL report (Ex.PW2/A) was suspect in as much ... Scientific Officer
Crl.A. 129/2003 Page 10 of 58
in the CFSL laboratory, on 14.08.1995, with the seal of V.S.B., SSO, CFSL
Ramtek, Sr. Scienlific Officer, Grade II
(Chemistry) CFSL, New Delhi
iv. PW-4 Sh. Pawan Singh, Nodal Officer, IDEA Cellular
v. PW-5 Sh. Ashok ... Deepak Kumar Tanwar, Sr. Scienlific Officer, Grade
II (Physics) CFSL, New Delhi
vii. PW-7 Sh. Rajesh Kumar Sharma, Senior Clerk, Northern
Railway
viii
which were received from
Hon'ble High Court were sent to CFSL, Chandigarh for seeking
its opinion if the same had been edited ... tampered with. CFSL,
Chandigarh had submitted its report dated 19.12.2006 giving the
opinion that the video recordings in the Hi 8 cassettes were
camera original
sent for forensic
examination and according to the report received from CFSL,
Chandigarh the opinion was given that the video recording was
camera original meaning ... officials of Excise Department
from the CDs which were prepared by CFSL, Chandigarh for the
purpose of investigation. The witness had identified the scene
relating
Voice sample of accused Vinod Kumar and Nitin Sharma
were taken at CFSL, Lodhi Road and same were sent alongwith original
instrument to CFSL, Lodhi ... Vigilance Branch and on the instructions of IO, he had gone to CFSL
and collected the exhibits and report which were duly sealed and after
Excise Act .
4. The said Hi 8 cassettes were forwarded to CFSL,
Chandigarh for obtaining its opinion on the question whether
they were edited ... tampered with. There was a report dated
19.12.2006 received from CFSL showing that the video
recordings in the said Hi 8 cassettes were camera originals
this dark pink colour) sealed
case. with the seal of 'CFSL
New Delhi Chem.Div.D.B'
He identified 50 Indian and having ... having no specific colour)
same. sealed with the seal of
'CFSL New Delhi
He also identified his signature Chem
containing specimen voice of accused M.S. Sangha was sent to
CFSL for obtaining expert's opinion. The cassette Ex.P14 containing
conversation ... produced in the Court in sealed
condition bearing seal of CFSL which proves the genuineness of the
cassette and that it was not tampered with
