Bachan Singh Negi vs Union Of India on 15 January, 2025
3. At the outset, learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the issue
involved in the present case has already been examined in detail in various
judgments, which are O.A.No.19/2019 and other connected OAs in the case
of Natvarbhai S. Makwana versus Union of India & Others decided
17.09.2019 by Hon'ble CAT, Ahmadabad Bench, O.A.No.011114/2017 - C.
Vasudevan vs. Union of India & Others decided on 28.11.2019 by Hon'ble
CAT, Ernakulam Bench, O.A.No.3756/2011 in Shakeel Ahmad Burney vs.
Union of India & Others decided on 03.11.2015 by Hon'ble CAT, Principal
Bench, New Delhi, Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in W.P. (C) 4131/2014 Union
of India & Others vs. Shakeel Ahmad Burney dated 05.08.2014,
O.A.No.114/2019 - Jairam Luniwal vs. Union of India & Others decided
on 05.05.2022 by Hon'ble CAT, Jaipur Bench, Hon'ble High Court of
Judicature for Rajasthan at Jodhpur in Writ Petition No.11709/2013
connected with other writ petitions in Union of Indian & Others vs. Har
Govind Sharma decided on 10.08.2015, Pooran Singh & Others vs. Union
of India & Others by CAT, Lucknow Bench dated 31.10.2013, Union of India
& Others vs Pooran Singh & Others decided on 18.01.2016 by CAT, Allahabad
Bench, CAT, Jodhpur Bench's order dated 22.05.2012 passed in the case of
Bhanwar Lal Regar Vs. Union of India & Others, CAT, Bangalore Bench's
order dated 14.03.2013 passed in the case of D. Sivakumar vs. Union of
India & Others in OA No.1088/2011, CAT, Bangalore Bench's order dated
17.01.2018 passed in the case of C.F. Tagadinamani vs. Union of India &
Others in O.A.No.946/2016, CAT, Ernakulam Bench's order dated 04.04.2019
passed in the case of V.D. Easow Vs. Union of India & Others in
O.A.No.950/2017 and other connected OAs, CAT, Bangalore Bench's order
dated 22.11.2017 passed in the case of G.B. Kulkarni vs. Union of India &
Others in O.A.No.852/2016 and other connected OAs.