The Anglo-French Textile Company Ltd. vs Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Madras on 8 December, 1953
36. and remanded the case to the High Court with the direction that it should give its opinion on these two questions. The High Court has accordingly considered these two questions which were referred to it for opinion and has answered Question No. 1 in the negative and against the assessee and Question. No 2 in the manner following, i.e., the income received in British India cannot be said to wholly arise in India within the meaning of Section 4A(c)(b) of the Act and that there should be allocation of the income between the various profit producing operations of the business of the company the light of the principle contained in the judgments in Ahmedbhai Umarbhai's case and in Anglo-French Textile Company v. Income-tax Commissioner relating to the same assessee.