M/S Chamundeswari Build vs Government Of Karnataka on 17 August, 2021
6.2 Thereafter, one more Report came to be submitted
by the jurisdictional Deputy Commissioner on 11.06.2014 and
in the said Report, the Deputy Commissioner has taken note
of the average of the highest sale transaction (by the
petitioner himself) executed in the vicinity of the lands in
question and calculated the market value at
Rs.980,04,51,144/-. Agitated by the Report, the petitioner
submitted objections to the Chairman of the Sub-Committee
18
on 18.06.2014. On perusal of the same, it is seen the
objection hovers around the adoption of the sale deed value
and reliance is placed on ruling of the Hon'ble Apex Court in
the land acquisition arena, more particularly, ruling rendered
in the cases of Naval Singh & Others Vs. Union of India &
Others, reported in 1995 SUPP (3) SCC 315 and Tarlochan
Singh and Another Vs. State of Punjab and Others
reported in (1995) 2 SCC 424. That apart, several other
objections are raised to the manner in which Report is
prepared and a request is made to accept the value fixed by
the erstwhile Deputy Commissioner on 07.07.2011 i.e., at the
rate of Rs.7,49,75,000/- as determined by the then Deputy
Commissioner one Sri. Chakravarthi Mohan (incidently the
petitioner has not sought for deduction of 50% as
recommended).