Manjit Singh Bali vs Department Of Posts on 15 November, 2018
In Sudhir Ranjan, Justice Rajiv Shakdher distinguished from the facts of
Surinder Pal Singh case and held "that ratio of that judgment would not apply to the
facts obtaining in the present (Sudhir Ranjan) case". Justice Shakdhar referred to the
apex court's judgment in (2003) 5 SCC 568 paragraph 23 that 'a little difference in
facts or additional facts may lead to a different conclusion".