24. We are also of the view that in the present case the first point of time
at which the Assessee could have raised this issue is only before the
Tribunal. It is only during the pendency of the appeals of the Assessee before
the Tribunal that the various decisions of the Tribunal holding similar
receipt of sales tax subsidy as capital receipt not chargeable to tax, were
rendered. The Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the case of CIT Vs.
M/S.Reliance Industries Ltd., by its judgment dated 15.4.2009 held that
identical sales tax subsidy was capital receipt not chargeable to tax. It was
in those circumstances that the Assessee made the claim by way of
additional ground before the Tribunal. The objection raised by the revenue is
therefore without any merit.