Shaikh Umar Ahmed Shaikh & Anr vs State Of Maharashtra on 28 April, 1998
37. Applying the law laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court of
India in judgment titled as 'Shaikh Umar Ahmed Shaikh & Anr
(supra)', this court is of considered opinion that identification of
accused persons namely Ram Narayan @ Sanjay and Irfan by
PW-1/complainant/victim Sh. Sharad Bhashkar Kokate and
PW-2/victim Sh. Somnath Nana Gaikwad in the court after they
FIR No. 194/2018, PS: Sarai Rohilla,
State Vs. Irfan & Ors. Page No. 34 of 50
were shown to them before the recording of their testimonies has
lost its evidentiary value and accused persons cannot be
convicted on the basis of identification of accused persons by
PW-1/complainant/victim Sh. Sharad Bhashkar Kokate and
PW-2/victim Sh. Somnath Nana Gaikwad in the court.