Kanshi Ram Jagan Nath And Others vs The State on 28 July, 1961
PW-2 F.I. Satish Kumar
Gupta confirmed in his cross-examination that sample
should be representative and analytic result of two
Analysts should be identical. To a specific question as
put by the Ld. Defence Counse, PW-2 F.I. Satish Kumar
Gupta deposed that he cannot say that if one Analyst
finds colour sunset yellow FCF in one counterpart and
another Analyst did not find the same, it is indicative of
the fact that the sample was not representative. No
explanation whatsoever has come on record on behalf of
the complainant in respect of divergent analytic results in
respect of artificial colouring matter and presence of
Lakh/Kesari Dal by the two Analyst in respect of
counterpart of same sample. Thereby relying upon
Kanshi Nath versus State (supra), I am of the considered
opinion that the sample was not representative."