Narender Chadha & Ors vs Union Of India & Ors on 11 February, 1986
19. The observations contained in paragraph-14 of Narendra Chadha's case supra, in the Judgment rendered by the Supreme Court while is not an authority for a proposition canvassed on behalf of the petitioner in the present situation, I do not find that such observations are also not in the nature of the law declared by the Supreme Court which is more in the nature of obiter, particularly, observing that if the Government by itself could have saved the situation and not disturbed the earlier employment of persons who had continued for as long as 15 to 20 years, they could do it. Even here, there is no direction issued in this regard to the Government. When such is the case, placing reliance on this decision of the Supreme Court, it is not possible to hold that the action taken by the employer is in any way wrong or illegal. Therefore, while this writ petition is to be dismissed and the interim order granted is to be vacated.