Rathis Chandra Munshi And Anr. vs Amulya Charan Ghatak on 25 February, 1930
5. It was urged by the learned advocate for the appellant on the authority of the decision in the case of Rathis Chandra v. Amulya Charan 1931 Cal 36 that the word "final" in the rules quoted above means final so far as the executive authorities are concerned and consequently the question can be tried again by the civil Court. That was however a case which arose out of an election under the Bengal Municipal Act in which there is an express proviso to Section 15 of the said Act retaining jurisdiction of the civil Courts to try suits relating to election. The learned advocate for the defendant-respondent, on the other hand contended that the word "final" in Rr. 1-A and 26-B means "not liable to be challenged in a civil suit."