Haradas Acharjya Chowdhuri, Lokenath ... vs The Secretary Of State For India on 2 July, 1917
6. Mr. Choudhury has relied very strongly on the case of Haradas Acharjya, Chowdhuri v. Secretary of State for India in Council 23 CLJ 590 : 43 Ind. Cas. 361 : 22 MLT 438 : (1918) MWN 28 : 20 Bom.LR 49 : AIR 1917 PC 86 (PC) and has contended that on such principles as have been laid down in that case, what he has proved is sufficient to lead to the inference that the land now assessed must be held to have been already assessed either as part of Touzi No. 424 or of some other permanently settled estate. We are unable to accept this contention ; we might nave endeavoured to do so if we had known the exact position of the river at the relevant dates and what changes the course of the river had exactly undergone between them.