10. We will confine ourselves to the question whether the relevant date of ascertaining the fact whether the candidate possessed the requisite qualifications was the date of last date of receipt of the application or whether it should be the subsequent date of selection. Even according to the learned single Judge, this question was squarely covered by the two decisions of the Apex Court in Rekha Chaturvedi (supra) and U.P. Public Service Commission (supra), which were not brought to the notice of the learned single Judge deciding Manishaben's case (supra).
10. We will confine ourselves to the question whether the relevant date of ascertaining the fact whether the candidate possessed the requisite qualifications was the date of last date of receipt of the application or whether it should be the subsequent date of selection. Even according to the learned single Judge, this question was squarely covered by the two decisions of the Apex Court in Rekha Chaturvedi (supra) and U.P. Public Service Commission (supra), which were not brought to the notice of the learned single Judge deciding Manishaben's case (supra).