Search Results Page

Search Results

1 - 10 of 22 (0.33 seconds)

Mrs. Kalyani Baskar vs Mrs. M. S. Sampoornam on 11 December, 2006

16.3 It is clear that in the above case the request for sending the cheques in question to the handwriting expert only made once by the accused and not as in this case on two occasions. Further in Kalyani Baskar, the decision of the learned MM rejecting the request was carried in revision to the High Court and thereafter to the Supreme Court. However, in the present case, the order dated 8th March 2006 was not challenged by the accused further after the dismissal of the revision petition. There is nothing in Kalyani Baskar which indicates that despite a Magistrate by a judicial order having rejected the request for referring the cheques in question to a handwriting expert, it can thereafter suo motu refer those very cheques to a handwriting expert. Indeed, if such a proposition were to be accepted, it would virtually amount to permitting the learned MM to either review his own order or the order of the predecessor. That is clearly impermissible in the scheme of the CrPC.
Supreme Court of India Cites 6 - Cited by 364 - L S Panta - Full Document

Ajit Savant Majagavi vs State Of Karnataka on 14 August, 1997

15. This was later reiterated by the Supreme Court in the judgment in Ajit Savant Majagvai v. State of Karnataka. The law that the trial court is free to exercise its powers for the ends of justice and refer a document for the opinion of an expert is fairly well settled. However, as far as the present case is concerned the question is whether after the learned MM has by a detailed order dated 8th March, 2006 rejected such a request, and the order has become final, he can at a subsequent stage suo motu refer the cheques in question for the opinion of the CFSL. The learned Counsel for the respondent was unable to point out any provision under the CrPC which permits that. Nor do any of the judgments referred to hereinabove contemplate such a situation.
Supreme Court of India Cites 26 - Cited by 228 - S S Ahmad - Full Document
1   2 3 Next