Jitendra Kumar Singh & Anr vs State Of U.P.& Ors on 8 January, 2010
17. Therefore, it is held that since the applicants No. 1 to 5, who belong to reserved category, availed relaxation in educational qualification and weightage in marks on account work experience in the same department, at par with the candidates of general category, so they are also entitled to be considered on merits, for the post of MTS, in general category, as no extra special benefit was availed by the reserved category candidates. The contrary arguments of learned counsel for the respondents and the contrary observations made in Madan Lals, Deepas and Suresh Pals case (supra), stricto sensu, deserve to be and are hereby repelled. On the contrary, the ratio of law laid down in the indicated judgment of Jatindra Kumar Singh case (supra) is mutatis mutandis applicable to the present controversy and is a complete answer to the problem in hand.