Union Of India And Another vs Madhav Gajanan Chaubal And Another on 18 September, 1996
“37.We, therefore, approve the view take in
Chakradhar case that there cannot be any
reservation in a single post cadre and we do not
approve the reasonings in Madhav case, Brij Lal
Thakur case and Bageshwari Prasad case,
upholding reservation in a single post cadre either
directly or by device of rotation of roster point.
Accordingly, the impugned decision in the case of
Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education &
Research cannot also be sustained. The review
petition made in Civil Appeal No.3175 of 1997 in
6/9
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Rev.Aplc(MD) No. 108 of 2018
the case of Post Graduate Institute of Medical
Education & Research, Chandigarh, is therefore
allowed and the judgment dated 2-5-1997 passed
in Civil Appeal No.3175 of 1997 is set aside.”