Thdc India Ltd vs R.K.Raturi on 8 July, 2014
11. This Court is of the view that the decision in the case of THDC India Ltd. (supra) is
not applicable to the information sought by the petitioner. In that case the question was
regarding ACR gradings /ratings considered in DPC proceedings. It is in that context
that this Court had held that ACR gradings and the marks awarded in DPC proceeding
could only be disclosed to the concerned employee and not to any other employee as that
would constitute third party information. This Court had further held that such
Page 3 of 4
information could be disclosed only if the CIC found that a larger public interest was
involved and further after following the procedure prescribed under Section 11(1) and
19(4) of the Act.