Shri Pyare Lal Verma vs Ministry Of Railway, Railway Board on 13 July, 2006
¾ "The prayer made by the petitioner for copies of the note sheets was
rejected by the UPSC. The appeal filed before the appellate authority was
also dismissed on 19.09.2006. The petitioner has thereafter, stated to
have filed an appeal before the CIC which was also dismissed on
03.10.2006. The petitioner who appears in person submits that the CIC
has now given a decision in January, 2007, Shri. Pyare Lal Verma Vs.
Ministry of Railways by virtue of which the CIC has held that the note
sheets form part of the file and public authorities should give copies of the
same. The petitioner in person prays that this matter may be remanded
back to CIC to enable the CIC to hear the parties afresh in the light of the
aforestated Full Bench judgment. Counsel for the respondents have no
objection. Consequently, taking into consideration the stand of the
parties, the present petition is disposed of with a direction to the CIC to
issue notice to the parties and thereafter pass an order in the matter.