Subash Projects & Marketing Ltd., 2012
(2) SCC 624, M/s Consolidated Engg. Enterprises v. Principal Secy.
Irrigation Deptt . and others ... Pallav Sheth v. Custodian , 2001 (7) SCC 549.
3. M/s Consolidated Engg. Enterprises v. Principal Secy.
Irrigation Deptt . and others
appellant relied upon the
judgment in the case of Consolidated Engineering Enterprises
v. Principal Secretary, Irrigation Department and others
reported ... that on 3rd April,
2008 the judgment in Consolidated Engineering Enterprises
(supra) was rendered in which the issue was whether the
proceeding under Section
India vs. Popular
Construction Co. , ( 2001) 8 SCC 470 and
Consolidated Engineering Enterprises vs.
Principal Secretary, Irrigation Department ,
(2008) 7 SCC 169, held that ... parties.
iv. The mandate of Popular Construction Case (supra)
and Consolidated Engineering Case (supra) wherein
the emphasis on ‘fixed period’ needs to be given effect
judgment of a larger Bench of this Court reported in
Consolidated Engg. Enterprises v. Irrigation Deptt. , (2008) 7 SCC
169 [“Consolidated Engg.”]. It was, therefore ... Madhya Pradesh and argued that this
Court’s judgment in Consolidated Engg. (supra), being a judgment of
three learned judges, would prevail over the judgment
learned single Judge of this Court in S. P. Consolidated Engineering Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India . . In that case, the learned Judge observed ... view of the learned Judge in the case of S. P. Consolidated Engineering Co. (P) Ltd. (supra) that because an application under Section
thereafter."
8 The Apex Court in M/s. Consolidated Engineering
Enterprises v. Principal Secretary, (Irrigation Department) and ors 1 has
held as under ... Arbitration Act. This view is reinforced
by the Apex Court in Consolidated Engineering (supra). Therefore,
having once permitted the Appellant to convert the Arbitration
Appeal
light of the judgment delivered in case M/s Consolidated
Engg. Enterprises vs. Principal Secy. Irrigation Deptt . and others, 2008
(2) RCR (Civil ... very much clear from the judgment delivered in case M/s
Consolidated Engg. Enterprises 's case (supra) that the provisions of
Section
been so held in State of
Goa vs. Western Builders3 and Consolidated Engineering
Enterprises vs. Principal Secretary, Irrigation Department
and others4.
15. Having stated thus ... 7SCC 169
SLP 39511/2013
10
16. In Consolidated Engineering Enterprises (supra),
the Court, while dealing with the conditions in which Section 14
will
Peoples' Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sardul Singh Caveeshar, , S.P. Consolidated Engineering Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India , , Firm Gulzarimal Gheeshalal v. Firm
learned counsel next referred to the decision reported in S. P. Consolidated Engineering Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India , , where the present question ... Srinidhi Ltd., 1950-1 Mad LJ 709 and S. P. Consolidated Engineering Co. Ltd. v. Union of India
