insertion of these Constitutional provisions.
He read extensively from the Constituent Assembly debates to
buttress his argument that the Constitution never envisaged the
Page ... Maharashtra Legislative Assembly
(Disqualifcation on Ground of Defection) Rules 1986. Mr Talekar
has also tendered to us the Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume
VIII and extracts
insertion of these Constitutional provisions.
He read extensively from the Constituent Assembly debates to
buttress his argument that the Constitution never envisaged the
Page ... Maharashtra Legislative Assembly
(Disqualifcation on Ground of Defection) Rules 1986. Mr Talekar
has also tendered to us the Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume
VIII and extracts
traced. Mr. Singhvi
submitted that as can be gleaned from the Constituent
Assembly Debates, the same clarify that the words "any
person" must
Constitution makers when they debated these Articles. The debate on these Articles took place in the Constituent Assembly on 2nd, 3rd and 6th December ... also questioned in the Constituent Assembly. It was painted but by Shri Ambedkar, Chairman of the Constituent Assembly that though similar provision existed
Ambedkar as well as other
members in the Constituent Assembly debates.
7. Mr. Rohit Deo, learned Acting Advocate General,
on the contrary, submits that ... debates in the Constituent Assembly wherein there was
almost unanimity amongst the Hon'ble Members of the
Constituent Assembly, that the greatest evil
state as whole and not to that of its constituent units.
49) Constituent assembly debates with respect to territorial
waters and Article ... been elaborately
answered by Dr. B. R Ambedkar in the constituent assembly
debates referred to above. Therefore, the Petitioners submits that
the territorial waters abutting
Chandrachud has placed on record the extracts of the
Constituent Assembly debate and in particular, the speech
delivered by Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar as well
been victims of social discrimination or
social disabilities.
16. That the Constituent Assembly Debates can be relied
upon as an aid to the interpretation ... From the conspectus of the aforesaid Constitutional
provisions, Constituent Assembly debates and decisions of the
Supreme Court, it appears to us that the question
Ministers".
22. The learned counsel for the petitioners
relying upon Constituent Assembly Debates; Official Report
and report of Sarkaria Commission contended that the
Constitution ... matters by the Council of Ministers.
Attention was invited to the Constituent Assembly Debates
Official Report, Vol.VIII, Page 41, Vol.III and Sarkaria
Commission
Patel, the first Home Minister of independent India, made
during the Constituent Assembly Debates, where he spoke
about the need of the senior secretaries giving ... patriotic, as
loyal and as sincere as myself."
(Ref: Constituent Assembly Debates. Vol.10 p. 50)
Now unfortunately, we have a situation where
