Union Powers Committee dated July 5, 1947 (see vol. V, Constituent Assembly Debates, page 60). List I then consisted of 87 entries and there ... report of the Union Powers Committee, dated July 5, 1947 (Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. 5, page 58):
We think that residuary powers should remain with
words of
prohibition. [46G; 49C-F]
(b) The Constituent Assembly debates show that the first
draft of the 3 lists was such that ... statement in the
report of the Union Powers Committee (Constituent Assembly
Debates) namely that the 'residuary subjects could only
relate to matters which, while
FRAMING OF INDIA’S CONSTITUTION’ BY B. SHIVARAO ...................................................... 27
J. THE CONSTITUENT ASSEMBLY DEBATES....................................................................................... 34
K. THE USE OF CONSTITUENT ASSEMBLY DEBATES .......................................................................... 49
L. CONCLUSIONS ... ABOUT HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVES INCLUDING THE LIGHT SHED BY THE
CONSTITUENT ASSEMBLY DEBATES ...................................................................................................... 51
M. ARTICLES IN THE CONSTITUTION, WHICH EMPLOY THE WORDS ‘SUBJECT
Union Powers Committee dated July 5, 1947 (see vol. V, Constituent Assembly Debates, page 60). List I then consisted of 87 entries and there ... report of the Union Powers Committee, dated July 5, 1947 (Constituent Assembly Debates, Vol. 5, page 58):
We think that residuary powers should remain with
Book No. 5 Vol. No. X-XII Index to Constituent Assembly debate was also quoted to the extent that as a matter no debate took ... reason, and to accommodate its legislation to circumstances.
38. Relying on Constituent Assembly Debate Book No. 1 page 417-426, it was contended that Article
Report reprinted by Lok Sabha Secretariat)
The draft article and the Constituent Assembly Debates in
unambiguous terms show that minority status of a group ... held that the
Constituent Assembly debates although not conclusive, yet the intention of
framers of the Constitution in enacting provisions of the Constitution can
throw
rejoinder.
7.1. The learned counsel has, while extensively relying on the
Constituent Assembly Debates, Preamble, and Article 38 of the
Constitution which enjoins the State ... Muniswamy Pillai and Mr. Sardar Nagappa, from the Constituent
Assembly Debates, to support his contention that reservation should not
be used by the forward class
also brought to the notice of this Court that that Constituent Assembly debates make it clear that minorities were recognised according to their strength ... those who were technically not minorities but minorities nonetheless. (See Constituent Assembly Debates Official Report reprinted by Lok Sabha Secretariat).
170. The draft article
interpretation of
the phrase “all the then Members of the Assembly” in Article 179(c) of
the Constitution to mean that the composition and strength ... import of Article 181; and
iii. The deliberations in the Constituent Assembly Debates.
24
PART D
e. In terms of the decision of this Court
insertion of these Constitutional provisions.
He read extensively from the Constituent Assembly debates to
buttress his argument that the Constitution never envisaged the
Page ... Maharashtra Legislative Assembly
(Disqualifcation on Ground of Defection) Rules 1986. Mr Talekar
has also tendered to us the Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume
VIII and extracts
