Bank referred the matter to
the Chief Vigilance Commissioner (for short 'CVC') for advice and the
Commissioner made a specific recommendation that ... authority could not impose a lesser punishment than what was
suggested by CVC without its concurrence. The Bank accordingly imposed
the penalty of compulsory retirement
short
"CBI") and Central Vigilance Commission (for short "CVC") have
preferred these appeals by special leave against the judgment and order ... moved on the ground that the
cases were never reported to CVC and the CVC has neither reviewed the
cases nor had considered them
also made certain
recommendations in respect of CBI and Central Vigilance Commission (CVC).
One of such recommendations was to confer statutory status to CVC ... this
Court in Vineet Narain1. Later on the Government introduced the CVC Bill,
1998 in the Lok Sabha on 7.12.1998. The CVC Bill
DoPT had made a reference to the Central Vigilance
Commission ("CVC" for short) on the cited subject, which was
responded ... CVC vide their letter dated 3rd June, 2003
and it conveyed its opinion as follows: -
"Department of Personnel & Training
may refer to their
have directed the Inquiry Officer to submit the report through the CVC. Under what provision this was done is not clear. In fact ... this conduct of the Inquiry Officer in sending its recommendation to CVC. But it appears he was not properly instructed as the finding, recorded
office memorandum dated 17th December, 2002, issued by the Central Vigilance Commission(CVC).
9. The office memorandum of CVC, (No. 12.02.1 CTE-6 dated 17th ... very stringent/very lax to restrict/ facilitate the entry of bidders, the CVC formulated the parameters to be followed. Relevant extracts of the circular
decision
under clause 4.18(d) of the Central Vigilance Commission Guidelines (‘CVC
Guidelines’) to cancel the tender and go for retender to make the tender ... learned Single Judge after examining clauses 4.17 and 4.18
of the CVC Guidelines which provide for procedure in case of a single
quote/single valid
entire file including the Central Vigilance Commission (for short
`CVC') advice was also placed before the competent authority. The
Disciplinary Authority expressed disagreement ... noticed in paragraph 6
of its judgment as under:-
"(a)Whether, CVC's advice should be made available
to the defender
another v. Union of India
and another [6] (commonly called as the CVC case). Mr. Shanti Bhushan
submitted that in that case this Court ... standards of
qualification for appointment to a public office.
17. In the CVC case a three judge Bench of this Court held that the
recommendation
Central Vigilance Commission Act, 2003
(hereinafter referred to as the "CVC Act") directed the records relating to
prosecution of twelve accused be placed ... before the Central Vigilance
Commission (hereinafter referred to as the "CVC") for scrutiny and
recommendation. CVC was added as a party. Basically this
