expectation is a relevant factor requiring due consideration in a fair decision-making process." In Sterling Computers Ltd. v. M. and N. Publications ... tests for judicial scrutiny the substance of the decision is not backed by the decision making process.
29. To examine and to appraise the actual
learned advocate for the petitioner has made following submissions:
(a) The decision making process suffers from material and procedural irregularity.
(b) The procedure suffers from ... standards.
5.11 In view of the above defects in the decision making process, the same suffers from arbitrariness, procedural impropriety, material irregularity, irrationality, unreasonableness, unfairness
decision is one which no
responsible authority acting reasonably and in accordance
with law could have reached. In other words, the decision
making process ... that a decision if challenged (the
decision having been arrived at through a valid process),
the constitutional Courts can interfere if the decision is
perverse
therefore, to substitute its own decision on merits for that of the Authority vested with the decision making process. Even otherwise, the Court ... stated earlier, to substitute our decision on merits for that of the Authority vested with the decision making process. We, accordingly, do not find
three member
Review Committee would vitiate the decision and the
whole decision making process would be tainted, the
contention is that it cannot be said ... Full Court, that he had influenced the decision
taken at three levels. The decision making process
cannot be said to be vitiated on the premise
from them arbitrarily. Though that
decision is not amenable to judicial review,
the court can examine the decisionmaking
process and interfere ... 10078/2018 CAV JUDGMENT
decision taken by the employer ought not to be
questioned but the decision making process can certainly
be subject to judicial
that whether the decision is
right or wrong is a separate aspect, but can it be said that the
decision making process is not justified ... also well-defined and limited and the
court can examine the decision making process which will reflect
about the reasonableness of the decision
stage of technical bid itself amounts to an arbitrary act and
decision making process is nothing but reflects a
colourable exercise of power ... learned advocate Mr. Bhaumik Dholariya has submitted
that since the decision making process is well within the
frame work of eligibility criteria and the decision
Counsel has submitted that what is under
challenge mainly is the decision making process by the
authority which, according to him smacks, mala fides,
favoritism ... 5992/2022 ORDER DATED: 21/04/2022
ground itself, the decision making process of the
respondent has to be held as flawed and consequently
further
Bvishal Oil And Energy Limited Through ... vs Oil And Natural Gas Corporation Limited on 18
