that in Sukhdev Singh case (supra), the principles laid down in
Dev Dutt case (supra) were held to be legally sound and received
approval ... Larger bench.
10. The learned counsel emphasized that Dev Dutt case (supra), had
authoritatively held that every entry in the ACR of the public servant
Dev Dutt (supra), Mr. Nath, learned counsel for
the petitioner, correctly submits that, in terms of the decision, rendered in
Dev Dutt 's case ... relevant paragraphs of the decision of the Supreme Court, in Dev
Dutt 's case (supra), read as under:
"12. It has been held
other cases upon the
Office Memorandum dated 11.05.1990 after coming into force of the
judgment in the case of Dev Dutt was highly improper ... Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar's case. However, in that case except
relying upon the observations made in Dev Dutt 's case (supra
Then came along the decision of the Supreme Court in Dev
Dutt's case (supra), wherein it was opined that over the decade ... Dev Dutt's case and
Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar 's case. With reference to the decision in Abhijit
Ghosh Dastidar 's case
observed in paras 17 and 18 of the Report in Dev Dutt [Dev Dutt v. Union of India ... complete agreement with the view in Dev Dutt [Dev Dutt v. Union of India
Supreme Court in Dev Dutts case, Abhijit Ghosh Dastidars case, and Sukhdev Singhs case (supra), the provisions contained ... case of Sukhdev Singhs case (supra), a three-Judge Bench of the Honble Supreme Court, declared the view taken in Dev Dutt
adverse ACRs of prior to 2008-2009 despite the judgment in Dev Dutt case. Further, it would mean that the Respondent No.1 is trying ... patently illegal as it restricts the scope of the judgment in Dev Dutt case (supra) to only future DPC held after
observed in
paras 17 and 18 of the Report in Dev Dutt [Dev
Dutt v. Union of India ... Dev
Dutt [Dev Dutt v. Union of India , (2008) 8 SCC 725] . In para
8 of the Report this Court with reference to the case
judgment of Hon'ble Supreme
Court in the case of Dev Dutt vs. Union of India , (2008) 8
SCC 725, the respondents have ... judgment
of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Dev Dutt (supra)
each and every entry has to be communicated to the
employee
Others (Civil Appeal No. 5892/2006), wherein the
law declared in Dev Dutt Vs Union of India and Others ... that before the
judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in Dev Dutt Vs. Union
of India and Ors (ibid), there was no procedure
