case is no
authority for the proposition that if direct recruits and
promotees are integrated into one class, they cannot be
classified for purposes ... Grade 'D' by direct recruitment, no differentiation could
be made an between him and the direct recruits in the matter
of promotion
Rules, and issuing appropriate directions for
reversion of the illegally promoted direct recruits as also
for preparation of seniority lists in accordance with the
judgment ... Engineers. The future recruitments to Bombay Service of
Engineers, Class II cadre shall be made by nomination of
candidates recruited direct by competitive examination, held
particular
year both by direct recruitment as also by promotion, those
promoted would rank senior to those who were directly
recruited. This amendment has been ... Asstt. Engineers by direct recruitment.
But the Tribunal while determining the inter-se seniority of
Promotees and Direct Recruits, applied the unamended Rule
Constitution, the
petitioners hold LCE diplomas. Some of them were directly
recruited as Supervisors in the State of Andhra. prior to
1st November ... others were directly recruited as
Supervisors in the State of Andhra Pradesh subsequent to
,hat date. Their grievance was that the Andhra Pradesh
Rules adversely
exercise to find out (in accordance with direction
no.2) as to whether the direct recruits taken into service are in excess of the
quota ... were comprised of three sources including the
direct recruitment, there was no justification to deprive the direct recruits of
their share in the temporary posts
Court and
allowed with the following directions:
(i) Promotees other than those covered by direction
(ii) and direct recruits, would not be governed ... High Court gave the following
directions:
(1) Promotees other than those covered by
direction (2) and direct recruits would not be governed by
the quota
post
which is to be filled up by direct recruitment, till a
direct recruit is appointed.
Rule 9: Appointment of direct recruits.-(1) No
person ... case of direct recruits, the older in
age shall be senior to the younger;
(ii) a member recruited by direct appointment
shall be senior
traditional tangle of inter-se seniority between the India Police Service Direct Recruits and U.P. State Police Service, Special Grade Deputy Superintendents of Police ... decide the controversy by a common judgment. The appellants were direct recruits of the years 1970 and 1973 into Indian Police Service and were allotted
grade 'D' of Train Examinations were filled by
(a) direct recruits i.e., apprentice train examiners who had
completed the prescribed period ... guarantee under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
Once the direct recruits and promotees were absorbed in one
cadre, they formed one class
reckoned as
follows :-
(i) Direct recruits of an earlier
examination shall rank above those recruited
from subsequent examination.
(ii) Direct recruits of any one examination ... follows
(i) Direct recruits of an earlier
examination shall rank above those recruited
from a subsequent examination.
(ii) Direct recruits of any one examination
shall
