2013 Smt. Manju V/s Bright Industries and others two dissenting judgments have been passed by President and Member. As such, the case should ... member. The dissenting judgments passed by President and Member are not final judgment and appeal is not maintainable against these two dissenting judgments.
In view
Chinnappa Reddy, J., in his dissenting judgment
19
summarised the position in law on this point as follows
(at page 591): (SCC p. 712, para
learned counsel argued that the State Commission has also relied on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in P.T. Koshy ... Justice K.S. Chaudhari, Presiding Member sent dissenting judgment. As Members of the Bench differed in their opinion, the matter was placed before
case (supra) in the light of aforesaid judgements of this Commission and judgment of Hon'ble Apex Court in Raja Vasi Reddy Komalavalli Kamba ... Justice K.S. Chaudhari, Presiding Member dictated dissenting judgment. As Members of the Bench differed in their opinion, the matter may be placed before
security of
securities is publicity." (Para 106 of Justice Chalameshwar dissent judgment)
59.Justice Chalameshwar quoted Ruma Pal, J. saying:
Consensus within the collegium
FCR577 Bellinger vs Bellinger, (2002) 1 All E.R. 311 (dissenting
judgment of Thorpe U at page 335) and A. vs West Yorkshire Police
Punjab Civil Service Rules. But the learned Chief Justice in his
dissenting judgment was not prepared to agree with the
majority that under such circumstances
Punjab Civil Service
Rules. But the learned Chief Justice in his dissenting judgment
was not prepared ta agree with the majority that under such
circumstances
especially in
the event of its contra view or dissent, have discussed the aforesaid
judgments of the different High Courts and recorded its own reasons ... fairness, the High Court
should record its dissent with reasons therefor. The judgment of the other
High Court, though not binding, have persuasive value which
article and not as an
infringement of copyright.
10. Relying upon the judgment of Hon'ble Delhi High Court
in the case ... DTAA. The Hon'ble High Court has also
dissented from the judgment of Hon'ble Karanataka High Court
in the case
