enquiry report, decision had been
taken for cancellation of the said DPC proceedings.
Thereafter, by consequential order dated 02.06.2005
(Annexure-P/2), which is also ... principle of natural justice as
before cancellation of the DPC proceedings, the
petitioner has not been granted any opportunity of
hearing and even no show
from the post of Senior Assistant to Superintendent
Grade-II, DPC proceedings dated 31.3.2015 (Annexure P-7) recommending promotion of
respondent No.4 and another ... Superintendent Grade II to the post of
Section Officer and also DPC proceedings dated 13.2.2007 (Annexure P-11)
recommending promotion of respondent No.8 Soma
whereby the petitioner has been directed to provide photocopies of
the DPC proceedings including the comparative grading statement
pertaining to the recommended candidates as well ... ensured. Therefore, we do not see any reason why the
DPC proceedings, specially, the comparative gradings of
those recommended for promotion should not be
disclosed
extracted herein
below:
"a) Attested Copy of DPC 2007 & attested copy of DPC 2008
proceedings for the post of AGMs.
b) Attested Copy ... allotted by DPC Members in DPC 2007
for the post of AGMs.
c) Attested Copy of Marks allotted by DPC Members in DPC
hand, directions have been given to supply copies of the DPC proceedings
containing the relative assessment of the officers concerned, and on the
other hand ... respondent sought the information regarding the
Departmental Promotion Committee proceedings („DPC‟ for short) and the
minutes of such proceedings this Court is further
been promoted.
13. Learned counsel for the respondents submits
that since DPC proceedings have been held illegal and
cancelled, the petitioner cannot be granted ... circumstances of
the case, when the order of cancellation of DPC
proceedings has been held illegal and set-aside by this
Court by the order
been filed for setting aside the impugned DPC proceedings
held for promotion to the post of MPS Grade-II in the year ... filled up for 41 posts
of MPS Grade-II and the DPC proceedings were held in
association with the MPSC for appointment by promotion
been filed for setting aside the impugned DPC proceedings
held for promotion to the post of MPS Grade-II in the year ... filled up for 41 posts
of MPS Grade-II and the DPC proceedings were held in
association with the MPSC for appointment by promotion
writ petition being WP(C) No. 166 of 2018 challenging the DPC
proceedings dated 03.02.2018; promotion order dated 03.02.2018 and
transfer and posting order dated ... this Court suspended the
DPC proceedings dated 03.02.2018, the promotion order dated 03.02.2018
and posting order dated 05.02.2018 until further orders. However, the
question
made strictly on the basis of merit. No
judicial review of DPC proceedings, which are ordinarily conducted
in accordance with the standing government instructions ... seen by the DPC,
but such submission of him is not tenable being totally contrary to the
record. DPC proceedings held
