hand, directions have been given to supply copies of the DPC proceedings
containing the relative assessment of the officers concerned, and on the
other hand ... respondent sought the information regarding the
Departmental Promotion Committee proceedings („DPC‟ for short) and the
minutes of such proceedings this Court is further
proceedings was withheld.
II. This has been examined and the following decisions have
been taken in the matter:-
1.0. Vigilance proceedings and disciplinary proceedings
should ... found suitable by
the DPC, the DPC minutes will be kept in a sealed cover. On
completion of vigilance/disciplinary proceedings if the
employee
remarks had been given regarding the
suitability of each candidate. The proceedings of DPC shows that while the
respondent ... present case, the proceedings before
DPC were guided by certain rules. The original DPC proceedings were
produced in sealed envelope for perusal. The DPC rules
length and on perusal of the
Recruitment Rules, copy of DPC proceedings, the material on record and
the decisions cited, I find that non-consideration ... conveyed to petitioners. However, I find that along with copy of
DPC proceedings of 30th July, 2001 in question, there is a comparative
chart disclosing
sealed cover, when sealed cover procedure was resorted to during the DPC proceedings, the applicant could not be promoted to higher positions, which would have ... That non-opening of the sealed cover envelope of the DPC proceedings in respect of his case had resulted in heavy loss and injury
officers considered have been found fit. We reiterate that normally in DPC proceedings, the DPC lays down the parameters/yardsticks on the basis of which ... Though not stated, it appears from the DPC proceedings conducted on 15.04.2013 that it was ACR which acted as the main hindrance to promotion
2014/002484), the Appellant stated that the information concerning DPC
proceedings/ notes sought by him has not been provided. The Respondents stated that
the file ... concerning the DPC proceedings was under submission to the higher authorities,
when the RTI application was filed. In response to our query, the Appellant stated
Respondents, like details of movable / immovable assets,
copy of the DPC proceedings etc. without citing any larger public interest. The Appellant
was not present ... Raturi decided on 8.7.2014 in regard to disclosure of DPC proceedings of
other employees:
"This Court is of the view that ACR grading/ratings
Department
and vide letter No.77701/DPC/ Q/II/ST-12 dated 17.05.2000 of the DPC
proceedings, the Department opined that the date of commutation ... usefully refer to the relevant
portion of the said DPC proceedings which reads as under:
“The case was examined in consultation with JAG Deptt this
receipt of this judgment. The original files
relating to the DPC proceedings bearing No. DEME-
2/Per/2009 (Amlarem), No. DEME-8A/Per/2009
(Jowai
