enquiry report, decision had been
taken for cancellation of the said DPC proceedings.
Thereafter, by consequential order dated 02.06.2005
(Annexure-P/2), which is also ... principle of natural justice as
before cancellation of the DPC proceedings, the
petitioner has not been granted any opportunity of
hearing and even no show
been promoted.
13. Learned counsel for the respondents submits
that since DPC proceedings have been held illegal and
cancelled, the petitioner cannot be granted ... circumstances of
the case, when the order of cancellation of DPC
proceedings has been held illegal and set-aside by this
Court by the order
respondent no. 1 to file his
counter along with the DPC proceedings and posted the matter
today.
[2] When the matter is taken up today ... respondent no. 1 informed this Court that he
has produced the DPC proceedings and the same is supplied to the
counsel for the petitioner
said ACR grading/ratings and their interview marks
contained in the DPC proceedings can be disclosed only to the concerned employee ... argument of the petitioner that the information with regard to the DPC proceedings
would fall within the exception provided under Section
said ACR grading/ratings and their interview marks
contained in the DPC proceedings can be disclosed only to the concerned employee ... Jayaram, O.P. Kala, Vijaykumar who are government servants and the DPC
proceedings so conducted. As I have already observed that ACRs of these employees
said ACR grading/ratings and their interview marks
contained in the DPC proceedings can be disclosed only to the concerned employee ... argument of the petitioner that the information with regard to the DPC proceedings
would fall within the exception provided under Section
directors (including Chairman) who rendered services during
their employment in ONGC; DPC proceedings for the years 2016-18 for all the disciplines, etc.
Page ... point no. 05 of the
application whereas he had sought DPC proceedings for all disciplines for the years 2016-18.
But, the CPIO had deliberately
case of the applicant-respondent herein
for promotion through the DPC proceedings held on 26.05.2017
and 28.08.2017.
6. On the contrary, it is contended vehemently
interference by the courts of law in the proceedings and
recommendations of DPC unless such ... DPC meetings are held
illegally or in gross violation of the rules or there is misgrading of
confidential reports. No judicial review of DPC proceedings
26th February, 2020 with request
to consider the review DPC proceedings in respect of the petitioner
and convey decision on the same ... 12th June, 2020 with request to
consider the review DPC proceedings in respect of the petitioner
and convey decision.
5. The aforesaid shows a total
