views to the High Court and must have complete and effective
consultation with the High Court in the matter. In the
instant case, therefore, before ... empty formality. It held that there was no
full and effective consultation with the High Court before
the State Government decided not to appoint anybody
lack of eligibility
but not on suitability and/or want of effective consultation process, which
grounds were taken later on by supplementary affidavits ... Once there is consultation, the content of that
consultation is beyond the scope of judicial review, though lack of effective
consultation could fall within
passed without effective
consultation with the Chief Justice of India.
'Consultation' under article 222(1) means
'effective consultation' and since ... passed without effective
consultation with the Chief Justice of India.
'Consultation' in article 222(1) means
"effective consultation" and since
contention of the petitioner that there is no effective consultation within the meaning of the said expression under section 78(1) of the said ... second ground of challenge, it relates to the absence of effective consultation prior to taking action under section 78 of the said Act. The learned
Bank. It was held (i) that there was no effective consultation with
the Federal Society and no consultation with the Reserve Bank of
India ... matter. In
view of this, according to him, there was an effective consultation
with the Federal Society, as contemplated by sub-section (1) of
Section
findings of the Hon'ble Minister to
the effect that there was no effective consultation with the Federal
Society and therefore, the order passed ... effective consultation is concerned, the learned
Single Judge has basically gone on the premise that consultation with
the Federal Society would mean consultation with
this petition is the
non-compliance of the mandatory requirement of effective consultation
with a federal society to which the respondent No.4-Society ... operative Societies Act.
According to him, since there is no effective consultation to the
said federal society, the order of supersession of the Managing
Body
circle co-operative union, to the effect that there was no
effective consultation before the supersession, it is necessary to
have a look at Section ... where one
authority is required to consult another, such consultation must
be meaningful. It must mean conscious and effective
consultation. There the issue was relating
concerned Judge, and only in public
interest, and after full and effective consultation with the Chief Justice
of India.
(vi & vii) A sixth writ ... further that,
it was not preceded by a full and effective consultation with the Chief
Justice of India.
It is therefore apparent, that the above
requiring the final decision to be taken after full interaction and effective consultation
between them, to ensure projection of all likely points of view ... purpose is best served if at the end of an effective consultative process between
all the consultees the decision is reached by consensus
