post of the respective workman was Deputy
Engineer and Executive Engineer, in fact, they were not discharging
Page 8 of 34
C/SA/196/2018 ... reason why a Junior
Engineer, who was subordinate to a Deputy Engineer, should not be
treated as a 'workman', who would be entitled
employees. AO denied the claim on the ground that software engineers
are not workmen. On appeal before ... joined as engineers in their respective field such as systems
engineer, test engineer, software design engineer, IC design
engineer, lead engineer etc. A cursory perusal
claims between the Diploma Engineers and Graduate Engineers. The Graduate Engineers Association, namely, the Andhra Pradesh State Electricity Board Assistant Engineers Association contends that inspite ... Assistant Engineers and 16 Additional Assistant Engineers were promoted as Assistant Divisional Engineers. The Diploma Engineers Association has nothing to do with
working in the cadre of Executive Engineer and Deputy
Engineer with the Gujarat Electricity Board are not workmen within
the meaning of Section ... Deputy Engineer and the
Executive Engineer of the then Gujarat Electricity Board, now the
Electricity Companies, are not the workmen within the meaning of
Section
working in the cadre of Executive Engineer
and Deputy Engineer with the Gujarat Electricity Board are not
workmen within the meaning of Section ... Deputy Engineer
and the Executive Engineer of the then Gujarat Electricity
Board, now the Electricity Companies, are not the workmen
within the meaning of Section
Yashmun Engineers Ltd. that these workmen are employees of Yashmun Engineers Ltd. It was further contended that these workmen are not being paid according ... that all the workmen were engaged by Yashmun Engineers Ltd. and workmen are the employees of the Yashmun Engineers Ltd. Yashmun Engineers
not workmen were contractully engaged and once they had specifically agreed to be terminated on the availability of the parsons who were not workmen were ... controversy whether an Engineer who does generally the duties of the Engineer is a workmen or not for the first time came before the Supreme
Even if they are not workmen can the workmen of the Board raise a dispute on behalf of the Assistant Engineers also if they have ... Engineers were allocated new duties and responsibilities apart from the duties and responsibilities of the Junior Engineers. Hence the Assistant Engineers are not workmen
members of six categories were held to be
workmen, namely (1) Transport Engineer (2) District
Engineers (3) Foreman (Chemicals), (4)- Fueling
Superintendents (5) Chemists ... Representative must be
held not to be workmen; and of the members of four
categories held not to be workmen, the tribunal erred with
respect
they should have done. The sectional
engineers in-charge asked these workmen as to why they did
not commence their work and became a ware ... not
commence work. The persuasions of the Chief Engineer and
also of the section engineers proved of no avail and the 76
workmen persisted
