Rather, the
respondents delayed convening the Departmental Promotion
Committee for regular promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer
(Civil) and filled the available vacancies ... post of Executive Engineer (Civil). However,
in order to deprive the eligible Assistant Engineers (Civil)/applicants
from promotion to the post of Executive Engineer (Civil
Rather, the
respondents delayed convening the Departmental Promotion
Committee for regular promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer
(Civil) and filled the available vacancies ... post of Executive Engineer (Civil). However,
in order to deprive the eligible Assistant Engineers (Civil)/applicants
from promotion to the post of Executive Engineer (Civil
follows:-
"11. In case of recruitment by : Promotion :-
promotion/deputation/transfer Assistant Engineer
grades from which promotion/ (Electrical) with 5 years
deputation/transfer ... Engineers in Civil or Mechanical is
the post of Assistant Engineers. The minimum period for Sub
Engineer to qualify for promotion to the post
degree-holder Junior Engineer, there being a quota fixed for graduate Junior Engineers and diploma-holder Junior Engineers for promotion to the post of Assistant ... their being a quota fixed for graduate Junior Engineers and diploma holder Junior Engineers for promotion on the post of Assistant Engineer. This is what
Regular promotion Promotion
Bio Metric Junior as as
Identification Engineer Assistant Excutive
(Civil) Engineer Engineer
(Civil) (Civil)
1 Hardayal 20.09.2000 16.07.2007 01.02.2020
Singh Meena ... years of service
are eligible for such promotion. The applicants were
considered for promotion as Executive Engineer (Civil) on
an ad hoc basis and were
serving/existing diploma holder sub-Divisional Engineer/Assistant Engineer (E) into the field of selection for promotion to the post of Executive Engineer (Electrical ... excludes the diploma holder Sub-Divisional Engineer/Assistant Engineer (E) from the field of selection for promotion to the post of Executive Engineer (E) merely
promotion on the post of Executive Engineer or Superintending Engineer, the promotion was made against regular vacancies that were available.
10. We may also advert ... when the applicants were promoted as Executive Engineer or Superintending Engineer, they were thus given ad hoc promotion against clear available vacancies. At the time
held in the UPSC, the fifth Respondent herein, for considering Executive Engineers for promotion to the grade of Superintending Engineers. Following the recommendations ... dated 31.07.2008, promoting 12 Executive Engineers to the grade of Superintending Engineers were issued. The Applicant was overlooked for promotion, whereas Mr. A.K. Pandey
methods
12. In case of recruitment by : Promotion:
promotion/ deputation/ (i) 50% by promotion of Assistant Engineers (Civil)
absorption grades from with 8 years regular ... next higher grade/posts i.e. Superintending
Engineer(Civil), Addl. Chief Engineer(Civil) as well as Chief
Engineer(Civil). Therefore, the applicants requested the respondent
Additional Chief Engineer,
Principal Director, HQ Chief Construction
Engineer (North East Projects),
Integrated HQ of Ministry of Defence (Army),
Engineer-in-Chief's Branch ... Service (MES) as
Assistant Executive Engineer w.e.f 20.01.1981. He got
5
promotions as Executive Engineer and Superintending
Engineer in due course. In terms
