comprised the posts of
Chief Engineer, Superintending Engineers, Executive
Engineers (Special Grade), Executive Engineers (Ordinary
Grade) and Assistant Engineers, while the Subordinate
Service comprised inter ... Engineer. 10. Junior Engineer.
2. Junior Engineer. 11. Junior Engineer.
3. Supervisor-Direct recruit. 12. Supr. direct recruit.
4. Junior Engineer. 13. Junior Engineer
posts of Junior Engineer, Assistant Engineer and Executive
Engineer. In the hierarchy of Engineering Cadre, the initial post is of
Junior Engineer (Section Officer ... diploma-holder Junior Engineers and graduate Junior
Engineers, from the post of Assistant Engineer to the post of
Executive Engineer. The diploma-holders
case of recruitment Promotion
by promotion/deputation/ 1. Section Officer
Transfer grades from which possessing a
promotion/deputation/ recognized degree
transfer to be made ... There is watertight compartment for graduate
Junior Engineers and diploma-holder Junior Engineers.
They are entitled for promotion in their respective quotas.
Neither a diploma
Regulations pertains to promotion and provides as
under :
“(9)(A) Promotion
In respect of first promotion to higher post, promotion of eligible person
shall ... degree-holder
Junior Engineer, there being a quota fixed for graduate Junior Engineers
and diploma-holder Junior Engineers for promotion to the post of Assistant
Bombay Service of Engineers Class II,
(b) Deputy Engineers confirmed from the subordinate services
of Engineers, (c) temporary deputy engineers recruited by
the Bombay Public ... service are the Chief Engineers,
Superintending Engineers and the Executive Engineers who
constitute class I service. The channels of promotion to
the cadre of Executive
Engineer was
being made by promotion of Assistant Executive Engineers and
Assistant Engineers. The promotion of Assistant Engineers as
Executive Engineers was governed by Rule ... educational qualifications for
promotion of Assistant Engineers to the cadre of Executive
Engineers and an Assistant Engineer though not a graduate
could be promoted provided
promotion is subject to the proviso that 90% of the post under the promotion quota would be filled up by promotion of Junior Engineers (Civil ... promotion is subject to the proviso that 90% of the post under the promotion quota would be filled up by promotion of Junior Engineers (Civil
promotion from the post of Junior Engineer to the post of Assistant Engineer in the Public Works Department. Promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer ... contemplates a provision that all the Junior Engineers and Junior Engineers (Technical) shall be eligible for promotion on the post of Assistant Engineer after confirmation
graduate
Engineer. The Rule specifically made difference of service
rendered as a graduate Junior Engineer and a diploma-holder
Junior Engineer. Degree-holder Engineer ... degree-holder Junior
Engineer, there being a quota fixed for graduate Junior Engineers
and diploma-holder Junior Engineers for promotion to the post of
Assistant
holder Assistant Engineer as Executive Engineers. Both these persons were senior to the appellant in the grade of Assistant Engineers and their promotion and appointment ... vacant posts of Executive Engineers. He stated that he had considered the cases of the departmental Assistant Engineers for promotion as Executive Engineers
