degree was not required.
11. The Rules pertaining to promotion as
Superintending Engineer fell for interpretation
before this Court in A.K. Raghumani ... December 1989 when these Sub-Engineers were
considered for promotion as Assistant Engineers.
Even otherwise, if this period of 8 years is counted
from
Superintending Engineer, Chief Engineer etc. and most of the
Junior Engineers have been superannuated before reaching the post
of Assistant Divisional Engineer itself ... Engineers, who did not complete 10 years of service as Junior
Engineer and who joined as Junior Engineers later to the Assistant
Engineers got promotion
graduate Engineer. The rule
specifically made difference of service rendered as a
graduate Junior Engineer and a diploma-holder Junior
Engineer. Degree-holder Engineer ... degree-holder Junior Engineer, there
being a quota fixed for graduate Junior Engineers and
diploma-holder Junior Engineers for promotion to the post
of Assistant
list of Assistant Engineers dated 30.08.2005. In the meantime, several Assistant Engineers were promoted to the post of Executive Engineer/Superintending Engineer as their names ... mean that they were granted promotion or they are entitled to claim promotion, in as much as, promotion can only be made on the recommendations
degree-holder Junior Engineer, there being a quota fixed for
graduate Junior Engineers and diploma-holder Junior
Engineers for promotion to the post of Assistant ... degree-holder
Junior Engineer, as a quota is fixed for graduate Junior Engineers and
diploma-holder Junior Engineers for promotion to the post of Assistant
Junior
re- Vice- Engineer/
59 designated 560- Chancellor Head
as Assistant 1200 Draftsman
Executive (Later on
Engineer) re-
designated
as Assistant
Engineer)
based on
seniority ... Institution of Engineers (India) in
Civil or Mechanical Engineering after appointment as
Assistant Executive Engineer shall be eligible for
promotion as Executive Engineer only after
prescribes to consider an eligible Superintending Engineer on the post of Chief Engineer (Civil), Level-2 through promotion, the Superintending Engineer must occupy the post ... post of Executive Engineer and Superintending Engineer and has been substantively serving on the post of Superintending Engineer at least for last one year shall
post of Executive
Engineer. All other posts, i.e., of Executive Engineer,
Superintending Engineer and Chief Engineer are promotional
posts. Rule 9 provides that ... Service, namely, Executive
Engineers, Superintending Engineers and Chief Engineers". It
is thus clear that the post of Chief Engineer is primarily a
promotional post
post of Assistant Engineer
Date of Appointment on the post of Executive Engineer
Date of appointment on the post of Superintending Engineer ... recruitment to the post of Chief Engineer-Level-II, Chief Engineer-Level-I and the Engineer-in-Chief shall be made on the basis
Chief Engineer, therefore, as per Rules, 1986 total 78 Superintendent Engineers (Civil) (three times to 26) should be eligible for being considered for promotion ... appointed Superintending Engineer and have completed one year service as Superintending Engineer and second, those have completed 25 years service as Assistant Engineer.
The petitioners
