each vertical category under ESM category.
5. It is argued that in this manner there has been excessive ESM
reservation under OBC category whereas under ... subsidiary of Coal India Limited
seems to have operated ESM reservation which is a horizontal category
reservation on the basis of horizontal-cum-overall reservation
therefore
ESM reservation applies to Group „B‟ posts in Chandigarh Administration
also. Hence, the challenge to horizontal reservation for ESM in PGT posts
is stated ... under the label "Gen-ESM" is contrary to law.
Even, if the respondents‟ contention that ESM horizontal reservation
applies to Group „B‟ posts
resolve the issue with respect to reservation of posts in
horizontal and vertical reservation and ESM category, an affidavit dated
30.10.2017 was filed by Vijay ... posts were reserved for ESM, the candidates belonging to
ESM category should have been adjusted against the posts reserved for
ESM category and could
been selected
against OBC-ESM. General-ESM candidates have been selected against UR-
ESM seats in the impugned provisional merit list. An attempt has been ... Trainee) have not considered the said
horizontal reservation and have given horizontal reservation for Ex-
servicemen (ESM) above 70% in OBC category for the post
would be
entitled to claim the benefit of reservation as ESM General category in the
instant advertisement as per instructions
ions dated ... post prior to his joining
service by availing the benefit of reservation as ESM could claim the benefit
again. Therefore, despite his appointment as Clerk
EPBG = 79, ESM Gen = 61 (5 backlog), ESM SC = 20 (4
backlog), ESM BCA = 17 (1 backlog), ESM ... reservation, whereas the reservation for categories
such as persons with disabilities and ex-servicemen is called
horizontal reservation. Horizontal reservation cuts across vertical
reservation
under consideration and it
has been decided as follows:
a) Reservation
The existing reservation in respect of civil posts for ex-
servicemen should be utilized ... 6451, dated the 6th March, 1972.
The reservation for ESM will be utilized in the order given below.-
i) Disabled ex-servicemen with disability between
Accountant)
General Category =20
Out of Total 14% Horizontal reservation
for ESM category,
7% Horizontal reservation for ESM
general candidate =03
____
Total posts for general ... reservation both
vertical and Horizontal.
THE PRESENT STATUS OF RESERVATION
(In direct recruitment for class-III & IV)
Category Vertical Horizontal
SC 20% 2% ESM
such she is very much entitled for the
benefit of reservation as ESM.
11. At the first blush, the contention seems to be attractive ... members of MNS are also to be
granted the benefit of reservation as ESM.
SANJAY GUPTA
2022.07.04 18:13
I attest to the accuracy
post advertised were to be filled by ESM
(BC-A) or BC-A (ESM). Social reservation remains on the front seat on the
basis ... reservation within reservation or to put it in another way;
social reservation under Article 16 (3) and (4) clubbed with special
reservation under Article
