resolve the issue with respect to reservation of posts in
horizontal and vertical reservation and ESM category, an affidavit dated
30.10.2017 was filed by Vijay ... posts were reserved for ESM, the candidates belonging to
ESM category should have been adjusted against the posts reserved for
ESM category and could
case involving horizontal reservation of female
category candidates and bears no semblance to horizontal reservation of
ESM or DESM.
5. It is the contention
post for sports and three were reserved for ESM by giving them
horizontal reservation. The candidates of these categories will
( O.A.NO. 060/00269 ... settled
proposition of law that horizontal reservation cut across vertical
reservation ( in what is called interlocking reservation) and the
person selected against these reservations
diversion of one (01) post from the ESM Category to General
Category in view of the reservation for the said category having exceeded.
The writ ... comprises of 8 posts and
as per the prescribed 13% reservation fixed for the
ESM category, only one post falls within quota of
ESM, therefore
hearing today, it is stated that there is no
reservation in the promotion for the ESM category, and in view of the
petitioner having submitted
availability of suitable candidates from Backward
Classes there will be 2% reservation for freedom
fighter/their children/grand children to that extent."
2. Learned ... counsel for the petitioner submits that 7 vacancies
remain unfilled in BCA-ESM category.
3. If Note 3 has to be given effect
been considered by the
Government and it has been held that horizontal reservation is a smaller
7 of 9
::: Downloaded ... reservation. It has,
therefore, been decided that in case, no candidate is found suitable for
appointment even on re-advertisement, the vacancies reserved for ESM
applied for the post of PGT (Computer Science) in the category of ESM
(Dependent) General category. The petitioner appeared in the written
examination ... prejudice will be caused as she is not seeking benefit of any
reservation or relaxation and therefore, the door cannot be shut totally, for
consideration
insufficient eligible candidates
being available and similarly 9 vacancies of the ESM category also could
not be filled up and all such vacancies were ordered ... said break-up in tabulated form is reproduced below:
General SC BC ESM Total
Requisition sent to SSSB 35 24 14 25 98
Recommended
petitioner intends to change his category from General to Ex-
service Man(ESM). It is held that such a change of criteria during the
process ... covered by the Sports Police of the
government by which 3% horizontal reservation is provided to
outstanding sport persons. Actually, he is belonging from
