court's jurisdiction to interfere with the discretion of an expert body is limited, even though right to education is concomitant to the fundamental ... delayed by any extraneous consideration. Thus, though the views of the expert body like the University may not be interfered with lightly, a proper mechanism
that the following vital issues need to be
answered by an Expert Body, who should be free from the
administrative control and/or influence ... make available the
above stated team of Experts as well as the Coordinator of the
Expert Body for organizing the meeting of the Expert Body
hearing before the 3rd Pay Commission. The
pay commission, being an expert body, is best suited to analyse the
nature of work and responsibilities ... principle must be left
to be evaluated and determined by an expert body. These are not
matters where a writ court can lightly interfere
order dated 9th
June, 2009, whereby besides constitution of an expert-body to
examine the victim and opine on the medical termination of her
pregnancy ... victim, we decided to obtain a second medical opinion
from an Expert Body comprising eminent experts from the Post-
Graduate Institute of Medical Education
other categories of employees was not disturbed
by any expert body such as the Pay Commission, but rather by a Cabinet Sub-
Committee ... year 2016, the
6th Punjab Pay Commission, which is an expert body, maintained the parity as
it existed under the 5th Pay Commission, which continued
examine the matter, given that the Pay Commission is an
expert body and, therefore, the notification dated 17.2.1989 was invalid as it
transgressed the recommendations ... cadre/cluster that too without the
issue being examined by the expert body. The Pay Commission is
admittedly an expert body and its recommendations should
service candidates.
The Medical Council of India is an expert body. Its assessment
about the method of determining merit of the competing
candidates must ... Supreme
Court the MCI Regulations have been framed by an Expert body based on
past experience. It has undergone repeated changes before it emerged
thrust in the appellant's contention is that
when an expert body i.e. Board of appointment
consisting of high academicians, has found Ganpat ... qualified and which has been approved by
the Syndicate, another expert body, the High Court
ought not to have acted as a Court of appeal
been exercised by the
Learned Single Judge but since the expert body i.e. Haryana Public
Service Commission had forwarded the name of the appellant ... eligible under the said Rules and give its recommendations
being the expert body. Unfortunately, the Commission was not arrayed
as a party respondent
such interviews. Therefore, the
assessment on merits as made by such an expert committee
cannot be brought in challenge only on the ground that ... appellate body and we are certainly not acting
as a court of appeal over the assessment made by such an
expert committee
