Natarajan for inclusion and placement in the select list on some extraneous consideration. The averments in the OA further proceeds to state that the above
Sushama Godbole vs D/O Personnel &Amp Training on 13 November, 2019
1 OA
bonafide and
reasonable. If the exercise of power is based on extraneous
consideration, the order of transfer is liable to be quashed."
There cannot ... party
array. No other person who may have had an extraneous consideration
in it other than the party respondent. The party respondent being a
Government
know whether it was meant for business purposes and not for extraneous consideration. In the case of Siddho Mal & Sons ... payment of such royalty was for business purposes or for extraneous consideration. He has further observed that the automatic approval by RBI as well
pointed out that if the transfer order is passed for extraneous consideration, the same cannot be said to have been passed.
5. Learned counsel appearing ... stand unless they are vitiated either by mala fides or by extraneous consideration without any factual background foundation. When, as in this case, the transfer
purely in public interest without any malafide or any irrelevant or extraneous consideration. Examining the ineffectiveness Peter Principle laid down ... arbitrary or vitiated either by mala fide or actuated by extraneous consideration or arbitrary in retiring the government officer compulsorily from service
transaction between assessee and tenants is inflacted by the
reason of extraneous consideration an ALV fixed by the Municipal limit
is not binding upon ... willing lessee uninfluenced by any extraneous
circumstances, (ii) an inflated or deflated rent based on extraneous
consideration may take it out of the bounds
mere
mistake of law, e.g., in the nature of some extraneous consideration
influencing the quasi judicial order. Since nothing of the sort is alleged ... disregard of judicial norms and on insufficient grounds and
based on extraneous consideration with oblique motive. A three
Judge Bench
Jain, interrogated him and gave
vide publicity in the press for extraneous
consideration.
(iv) Shri Ashok Aggarwal showed lack of restraint and
used his powers ... summoning Shri Amit
Burman u/s 40 of the FERA for extraneous
consideration, without making any inquiries and
without issuing a directive
Shashank Deepak vs Defence on 9 September, 2022
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
LUCKNOW BENCH LUCKNOW
ORIGINAL