only the respondents herein alone have been terminated on malafide and extraneous consideration.
11.The learned senior counsel strongly contended that it is not true ... appellant are stigmatic, punitive and passed on malafide and extraneous consideration.
i).Whether the 1st appellant is an instrumentality of the State coming under
applying its
mind in a proper perspective and accorded sanction on extraneous consideration.
5 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ... advise of the CVC, the sanctioning
authority had accorded sanction on extraneous consideration and it was not a
valid sanction, as such no cognizance
applying its
mind in a proper perspective and accorded sanction on extraneous consideration.
5 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ... advise of the CVC, the sanctioning
authority had accorded sanction on extraneous consideration and it was not a
valid sanction, as such no cognizance
been initiated in the absence of any imputation of mala fides, extraneous consideration, corruption or negligence while discharging such quasi-judicial function.
(2) The order ... mere mistake of law, e.g., in the nature of some extraneous consideration influencing the quasi-judicial order. Since nothing of the sort is alleged
urged mat the action of the Returning Officer is based on extraneous consideration and due to political pressure.
8. The petitioner ... with law and other allegations such as rejection was due to extraneous consideration, arbitrary in nature are denied as false and frivolous. He has further
specific allegation of culpable negligence or malafide intention or
allegation of extraneous consideration, the respondents cannot
initiate disciplinary proceedings against the petitioner. According ... acted with
culpable negligence or ill-motive or on some extraneous
consideration. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Zunjarrap Bhikaji
Nagarkar v. Union
charge-sheet against a quasi-judicial authority, something more i.e. extraneous consideration influencing quasi-judicial order, deliberate act or actuated by malafide ... levelled against the first respondent without any other allegation such as extraneous consideration, deliberate or malafide would not amount to misconduct, so as to initiate
clause or if he has introduced the said clause on some extraneous consideration. It has also been argued by the learned counsel for the appellant ... fide one or the Governor has passed the order on some extraneous consideration."
12. In the last judgment cited on the part
will amount to not only non-application of mind but also consideration of extraneous materials vitiating the order of detention.
7. The submissions made ... ground of arbitrariness.
11. There is non-application of mind and consideration of extraneous materials by the detaining authority, as rightly contended by the learned
April 2007, is vitiated by non-application of mind and extraneous consideration. The first Tender Notification in December 2006 has been scrapped on account ... application of mind and there is no place for extraneous consideration as contended by the petitioner.
25. It is the case of the respondents that
