10692/2018 CAV JUDGMENT
extraneous consideration have prevailed. He has submitted that in
the present case, it is found by the authorities that right from ... entire exercise of power is in collusion or with any
extraneous consideration. The Court has observed thus;-
Page 16 of 23
Downloaded
their matters, it
was by way of favouritism or with any extraneous
consideration. Mr.Naik further submitted that
against the decision on judicial side ... made that power is exercised by way
of favouritism or with extraneous consideration,
much higher degree of proof is required, which is
lacking
exercise the power if the
decision is tainted with any extraneous consideration or
is on the basis of the ground or the circumstance, which
cannot ... germane circumstances on the
face of it or is based on extraneous consideration, the
Court may interfere in exercise of power under Article
exercise the
power if the decision is tainted with any
extraneous consideration or is on the basis of
the ground or the circumstance, which cannot ... nongermane
circumstances on the face of it or is based on
extraneous consideration, the Court may
interfere in exercise of power under Article
exercise the
power if the decision is tainted with any
extraneous consideration or is on the basis of
Page 7 of 16
C/CA/4296 ... germane
circumstances on the face of it or is based on
extraneous consideration, the Court may interfere
Page 8 of 16
C/CA/4296/2015
application by the State of Gujarat is wholly irrelevant and an extraneous consideration. The fact that after late surrender as many as eight times furlough ... case, it is suffice to say that it is absolutely an extraneous consideration, at this stage, in the matter. If this consideration is relevant
competent authority was vitiated since he was influenced by an extraneous consideration regarding the concealment of the clandestine income of the husband of the transferee ... grievance that the competent authority was influenced by an absolutely extraneous and irrelevant consideration while considering the possible tax effect of not stating the fair
case where the exercise of power is in collusion or with extraneous consideration, it may stand on a different footing. In a case where ... favour of the beneficiary is in collusion with the officer or extraneous consideration prevailed. Nowhere through out in the proceedings the authorities have found that
Bharatsinh Himmatsinh Champavat & 2 vs State Of Gujarat & 3 on 6 August, 2015
exercise of his judicial
capacity. In exercise of his extraneous consideration,
Mr.Shah would submit that the penalty was
Page 4 of 15
Downloaded ... exercising quasi judicial powers, act was
actuated by corrupt motive and extraneous
consideration, it was not open for the disciplinary
authority to expose an employee
