allegation that the bail order was passed by
the appellant for extraneous consideration with oblique
motives on insufficient grounds and that the appellant was
guilty ... disregard of judicial
norms and on insufficient grounds and based on extraneous
consideration with oblique motive and the charges had been
proved. It is important
only shows that the appellant had no
malice or motive towards extraneous consideration, since
if the appellant had already pre-decided that he would
grant ... bail to the accused K.K. Jalia due to any extraneous
consideration, then the appellant would never have
passed a contradictory order in the first
line with WBSEB for the purpose of uniformity. This is
an extraneous consideration and contrary to requirements of
Sixth Schedule of the Supply Act . Sixth ... extraneous
consideration has been taken into account. Relevant
consideration is that for revision in tariff there should be
reasonable profit and extraneous consideration is that
scanned by the
court. A legislature does not act on extraneous
consideration. But for lack of legislative competence or
for being arbitrary, a legislative action ... long the policy is not vitiated by any
mala fide or extraneous consideration the courts have
neither jurisdiction nor adequately furnished with material
to adjudicate
been made bona fide, but
for collateral purposes and for extraneous consideration by
way of punishment and is, therefore, illegal, unwarranted
and liable ... Bihar Service Code, 1979 or for any oblique
motive as an extraneous consideration or by way of punish-
ment casting stigma on the service career
Judicial Magistrate is without
jurisdiction raising the presumption of extraneous consideration.
Your aforesaid act of granting bail to accused under ... officer. In a case of
grant of bail for extraneous consideration, there may not be direct
and tangible evidence available, therefore impressions have
comes to a conclusion
that the decision is on account of extraneous consideration
or it makes a hostile discrimination and arbitrary in
nature ... such equivalence unless it is
shown that it was made with extraneous consideration.
Bearing in mind the aforesaid parameters and on examining
the impugned judgment
that the said decision of the Improvement
Trust was either for extraneous consideration or had not
been taken bona fide. In course of hearing ... that decision can be
said to have been taken on some extraneous consideration.
We also fail to appreciate the conclusion of the High Court
hold
that a decision was taken by the Board on extraneous
consideration is to cast aspersion on the members of the
Committee and the Chairman ... merits and not on account of any political or
other extraneous consideration.
The Court then said;
"For the present, we are not expressing
could not be said that the appellant was actuated by
extraneous consideration as alleged ... Hence, merely because an enhanced
compensation was awarded, no inference of extraneous
consideration could be drawn. Mere suspicion was not
sufficient to prove that
