G.P. Doval And Others vs The Chief Secretarygovernment Of U.P. ... on 18 July, 1984
Equivalent citations ... Desai
Bench: D.A. Desai , Amarendra Nath Sen
PETITIONER:
G.P. DOVAL AND OTHERS
Vs.
RESPONDENT:
THE CHIEF SECRETARYGOVERNMENT OF U.P. AND ORS.
DATE
placed
reliance on the following decisions of the Supreme Court:-
1) G.P. Doval and Others v. Chief Secretary, Government
of U.P. and Others ... decision was that of the Supreme Court in
the case of G.P. Doval (supra). Paragraph 16 of the said decision had
been relied upon
Rabindranath Base v. Union of India ).”
(Emphasis Supplied)
33. In G.P. Doval & Ors v. Chief Secretary, Government of U.P. & Ors ,
reported
P, [1981] 1 SCR
449 at 469; A. Janardhan v. Union of India, AIR 1983 SC 769
= 1983 2 SCR 936; G.P. Doval ... valid and would satisfy the tests of Article 16."
In G.P. Doval v. Chief Secretary, Government of U.P
treated differently.
24.In so far as the contentions raised in W.P.No.14580 of 2011 is concerned, the learned counsel submitted that ... their contentions, the learned counsels would rely upon the following judgments:
G.P.DOVAL AND OTHERS vs. CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVERNMENT OF U.P. AND OTHERS
fortify our view by the judgment of this Court in G.P. Doval v. Govt. of U.P.
39. The respondents have, in support ... here also appropriately refer to another decision of this Court in G.P. Doval v. Govt. of U.P. wherein this Court held that regularisation
Raje Ram Sheoran and Ors .
3) (1984) 4 SCC 329, G.P. Doval and Ors. Vs. The Chief Secretary, Government of U.P ... same strictly as per Regulations, 1970.
46. In the case of G.P. Doval (supra), the court was considering as to what would constitute substantive
Samar Roy & Ors vs Partha Sarathi Sen & Ors on 11 May, 2018
Author
decisions of the apex Court in the cases of G.P.
Doval and others v. Chief Secretary, Government of
U.P. and others ... which has come into force with effect from
01.01.2005.
8. In G.P. Doval (supra), the apex Court held that if
the first appointment
learned single Judge referred to pronouncement of the Supreme Court in G.P. Doval v. Chief Secy. Govt. of U.P. , amongst of her pronouncements ... been reiterated in the subsequent pronouncement of the Supreme Court in G.P. Doval v. Chief Secy. Government of U.P. . There , in that case
