submissions, reliance was placed on the
following decisions:
(i) 2000 (2) GLR 1784 in the case of Rajenbhai
Baldevbhai Shah Vs. Baijiben Kababhai Patanwadia ... case of Dilboo Vs. Dhanraj
and ors.
(ii) (2013) 1 GLR 398 in the case of Becharbhai
Zaverbhai Patel Vs. Jasubhai Patel
submissions, reliance was placed on the
following decisions:
(i) 2000 (2) GLR 1784 in the case of Rajenbhai
Baldevbhai Shah Vs. Baijiben Kababhai Patanwadia ... case of Dilboo Vs. Dhanraj
and ors.
(ii) (2013) 1 GLR 398 in the case of Becharbhai
Zaverbhai Patel Vs. Jasubhai Patel
Gujarat &
Another vs. Mahendrakumar Bhagvandas & Another
reported in 2011 (2) GLR 1290 and thus illegal and bad in
law and thus violative ... this Court
in V.A. Parekh Vs. State of Gujarat [2009 (5) GLR
3922] made following observations:
(1) It is immaterial that in a previous
State of Gujarat & Anr., Vs.
Mahendrakumar Bhagvandas & Anr. , [2011 (2)
GLR 1290] reads as under:
"In all these petitions, the petitioners while ... State of Gujarat &
Anr., Vs. Mahendrakumar Bhagvandas & Anr. ,
[2011 (2) GLR 1290]. Still, however, the State has
preferred to oppose the petitions
this Court in V.A. Parekh Vs. State of
Gujarat [2009 (5) GLR 3922] made following
observations:
(1) It is immaterial that in a previous ... State of Gujarat &
Anr., Vs.
Mahendrakumar
Bhagvandas & Anr. ,
[2011 (2) GLR 1290]
Para
Nos.5
and 8.
2 Transport State of Gujarat
State of Gujarat & Anr., Vs.
Mahendrakumar Bhagvandas & Anr. , [2011 (2)
GLR 1290] reads as under:
"In all these petitions, the petitioners while ... State of Gujarat &
Anr., Vs. Mahendrakumar Bhagvandas & Anr. ,
[2011 (2) GLR 1290]. Still, however, the State has
preferred to oppose the petitions
State of Gujarat & Anr., Vs.
Mahendrakumar Bhagvandas & Anr. , [2011 (2) GLR
1290] reads as under:
"In all these petitions, the petitioners while ... State of
Gujarat & Anr., Vs. Mahendrakumar
Bhagvandas & Anr. , [2011 (2) GLR 1290]. Still,
however, the State has preferred to oppose the
petitions
enforcement
of the order made by him. [Govindsingh
Ramsinghbhai Vaghela [1970 (11) GLR 897].
(ii) This power is obviously conferred upon the
Collector to secure ... salutary and beneficent provisions of the Act.
[Govindsingh Ramsinghbhai Vaghela [1970
(11) GLR 897].
(iii) Sub-section (3) of Section 9 does
Budhiben
Muljibhai Patel vs. State of Gujarat , reported in 2016 (2) GLR
1786.
(C) Mr.Rajguru, learned advocate, would further submit that the
orders ... case of Chhaganbhai Patel vs. Sitaben
Bhanabhai Rathod. , reported in 1988 (1) GLR 59.
(D) Mr. Shukla, learned advocate, would further submit that
there
Commissioner of Police, Vadodara reported in 1984
Vol.25(1) GLR 538.
viii. Natvarsinh Ramsinh Rathod Vs. State of Gujarat
reported ... GLR 1036.
Page 11 of 19
Downloaded on : Thu Sep 02 04:16:37 IST 2021
C/SCA/799/2019 CAV ORDER DATED
