weightage marks shall be awarded following the Grading Systemas detailed in para 7 of G.O.Ms.No.252 dated 05.10.2012 as amended ... paras (i) to (vi) above. They are aggrieved by the Grading System adopted [vide sub para (vii) above] in the Government Orders.
42. Paragraph
candidates are subsequently made in the form of Grade under the Stanine Grading System and according to the Institution, selection in the said manner ... Institution for selection is unfair and not transparent;
(ii) The stanine grading system is not only un-understandable and in that sense of view
with
importance of interview. The learned Special Government Pleader
contended that grading system adopted by the second respondent
17/28
http://www.judis ... with the grading methodology as
indicated supra in para 9. The appellants have not only
challenged the new grading system introduced by GOMs
Humanities/Arts with 50% marks (or an equivalent grade in a point scale wherever grading system is followed);
2. M.Ed. with at least ... marks (or an equivalent grade in a point scale wherever grading system is followed); and
3. Any other stipulation prescribed by the UGC/any such
Grade-B and
those who had scored above 60 percentile are awarded Grade-
C+. Those who had scored above 40 percentile are awarded
Grade ... merits of
the candidates.
II. CONVERSION OF MARKS INTO A GRADING SYSTEM OFFENDING
THE TEST OF TRANSPARENCY:
35. As stated in paragraphs
Grade-B and those who had scored above 60 percentile are awarded Grade-C+. Those who had scored above 40 percentile are awarded Grade ... merits of the candidates.
II. CONVERSION OF MARKS INTO A GRADING SYSTEM OFFENDING THE TEST OF TRANSPARENCY:
35. As stated in paragraphs
SYSTEM)
| |
ASSISTANT ENGINEER / ASSISTANT ENGINEER /
ELECTRICAL MECHANICAL
(COVERED UNDER COMMON (COVERED UNDER COMMON
CADRE SYSTEM) CADRE SYSTEM)
| |
ELECTRICAL SUPERVISORS
(SUPERVISORY 'C' GRADE)
(COVERED ... same grade, i.e. Supervisory "C" Grade without any reasonable classification.
9. It is also submitted, that introduction of Common Grade System could
been awarded to qualify a candidate for the course such as Grading System etc. A detailed reply may be furnished.
Not applicable to Diploma ... Grade - II and from the year 1981 for the post Lab Technician Grade - II and from the year 1981 for the post Lab Technician Grade
with at least 55% marks (or an equivalent grade
in a point scale wherever grading system is followed).
iii. A minimum of eight years ... Geology with
atleast 55% marks or an equivalent grade in a point scale wherever grading
system is followed.
(ii) Ph.D. Degree in Geology/Geophysics
A.B.Natarajan vs The Secretary on 10 July, 2009
Author: P.Jyothimani
Bench: P
