also asked the learned Counsel as to whether a marking or grading system was followed by the selection committee to judge the comparative merits ... respect of the post in question shows that no marking or grading system was followed by the said selection committee. The noting in respect
Meghana Dilip Talekar And Anr vs Maharashtra Legislature Secretariat ... on 9 July, 2019
Author: Akil
Vilas Gotiramji Athawale vs Maharashtra Legislature Srecretariat ... on 9 July, 2019
Author: Akil Kureshi
Bench
Meghana Dilip Talekar And Anr vs Maharashtra Legislature Secretariat ... on 9 July, 2019
Equivalent citations
decided to include total
marks and percentage along with grades in the statement of marks.
After the decision, the grading system for all courses ... marks and above the grade was O; for 70 percentage of marks and
above the grade was A+; for 60 percentage of marks and above
raised by learned counsel for the
petitioner is that, no marking or grading system was followed by
Selection Committee and, therefore, the selection process ... marking and
grading system and, therefore, such objection cannot be
considered across the bar. Be that as it may, such grading and
marking system
dated 27.06.2016, thereby introducing a marking / grading system
and 18.05.2018, thereby prescribing terms, conditions and selection
of residential schools.
2. In 2017, the department permitted ... order dated 04.07.2017, after
conducting a proper inspection and providing gradation of marks.
Thereafter, for every academic year up to 2024-2025, the department
direct recruitment to
marks (or an equivalent teaching positions. The
grade in a point scale eligibility marks of 55%
wherever grading system is marks ... equivalent
follwoed) and the relaxation grade in a point scale
of 5% tot he categories wherever grading system is
mentioned above are followed
Rule 6(1)(e) to the extent that it prescribes
minimum qualifying marks in the viva-voce test is violative of the judgment of
the Apex ... marks prescribed for the written examination.
We recommend that the method of "Evaluation by
Grading System" be followed.
Hence the Shetty Commission left
Dwarika Prasad vs Oil And Natural Gas Corpn. Ltd. And 3 Ors on 22 September
