JUDGMENT DATED: 27/10/2023
undefined
petitioner, who is practicing as a Gynecologist at Jamnagar
and she was illegally examining foetus by charging a huge ... reside in Mehsana. Thereafter, he started working
as a full time Gynecologist with Smt. Savitaben Ramanlal
Dahyalal Shah Sarvajanik Hospital & Prasuti Gruh Trust,
Ambasan
applicant is a practicing doctor since last many
years at Jamnagar as Gynecologist and is running a
maternity home in the name of "Nirmal ... complaints
were received against the petitioner, who is practicing as a
Gynecologist at Jamnagar and she was illegally examining
foetus by charging a huge amount
another
Medical Officer working in K.C. General Hospital.
She is not gynecologist, but PW9 is the gynecologist.
As per prosecution she had examined ... would speak that there is opinion of
gynecologist "that on the basis of clinical findings
intercourse might have occurred." Based on this
opinion
pregnancy
is asked for if the patient has given complaints to the gynecologist like
S.C. No.: 14/2012 15/29
bleeding, spotting, pain ... abnormal point in the normal report
format so that the gynecologist can take further action. He admitted that
his report did not mention about fetal
done by Dr.D.M.Patel, and in the opinion of
the Gynecologist, there was no evidence of any penetration in
the vagina. The blood ... opinion, he
also relied on the opinion expressed by the Gynecologist
Dr.Patel. He has deposed that he had also read the history
which
would advise hysterectomy ?
Ans: It has to be decided by the gynecologist.
(The witness volunteers in this case the patient
Mrs.Singhi was therefore referred ... gynecologist Dr.Alfred
Brockunier) (The witness further volunteers that in the
opinion of Dr.Alfred Brockunier surgery was not appropriate
looking to the condition
same day by Dr. Suganthi (P.W.7) (a gynecologist) who
prepared a report Ex.P9.
xii.The forensic report ... spot after the incident took place. It was also
contended that the gynecologist Dr. Suganthi (P.W.7) neither found injuries
on the private parts
same day by Dr. Suganthi (P.W.7) (a gynecologist) who
prepared a report Ex.P9.
xii.The forensic report ... spot after the incident took place. It was also
contended that the gynecologist Dr. Suganthi (P.W.7) neither found injuries
on the private parts
beyond reasonable doubt. Dr. Boriwal himself admitted that he is not
a Gynecologist, no expert medical witness was examined by the
prosecution. Gangabai ... Boriwal (PW-5) himself has admitted that he is
not a Gynecologist, but postmortem was jointly conducted by Dr.
Smt. Bahal
stated that the victim was subjected to examination by
dentist, radiologist and gynecologist to confirm her age
and the sexual assault. He has stated that ... approximate age of the victim is between 18-19 years. As
per Gynecologist, Hymen was ruptured, but it may not
necessarily attributable to sexual intercourse
