Hamda Ammal vs Avadiappa Pathar And 3 Others on 7 November, 1990
Equivalent citations: 1990 SCR, SUPL ... Bench: T.K. Thommen , K.N. Saikia , N.M. Kasliwal
PETITIONER:
HAMDA AMMAL
Vs.
RESPONDENT:
AVADIAPPA PATHAR AND 3 OTHERS
DATE OF JUDGMENT
objection and not by a separate suit."
13. In Hamda Ammal Vs. Avadiappa Pathar : (1991) 1 SCC
715, the appellant Hamda Ammal purchased ... suit.
14. Advocate Sri.James Vincent submitted that the decision in
Hamda Ammal 's case was rendered in respect of a case which
context. He relied on the decisions of the Supreme Court in Hamda Ammal v. Avadiappa Pathar ... attachment.
9. Same question came before the Supreme Court in Hamda Ammal v. Ayadiappa Pathan and 3 Ors., JT 1990 (4) SC 391. In that
proper perspective, and the
judgment of the Apex Court in Hamda Ammal v. Avadiappa
Pathar [(1991) 1 SCC 715] was not considered properly.
8. Learned ... Court also placed reliance upon judgment of
the Apex Court in Hamda Ammal (supra) wherein the Apex
RFA (Misc
Judge of this Court which we shall discuss presently.
19. In Hamda Ammal v. Avadiappa Pathar and Ors. , , the Supreme Court was dealing with ... somewhat similar question on that point. In that case, Hamda Ammal purchased the suit property by a sale deed dated 9-9-1970 which
decisions of the Supreme Court in Hamda Ammal v. Avadiappa Pathar 1991 ( 1) SCC 715 and Thakur Kishan Singh v. Arvind Kumar ... decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Hamda Ammal v. Avadiappa Pathar (supra) wherein the appellant before the Supreme Court purchased a property
decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Hamda Ammal v. Avadiappa Pathar [1991] 1 SCC 715. That was a case where Hamda Ammal ... Revenue that the decision of the Supreme Court in Hamda Ammal v. Avadiappa Pathar [1991] 1 SCC 715 was not a tax case and could
exposition of the Apex Court in the case of Hamda Ammal v. Avadiappa Pathar and 3 Ors. . Even in that case , Sale Deed was executed ... favour of Hamda Ammal on September 9, 1970 which was registered on October 26, 1970. Before registration of the Sale Deed, however, the Respondent Avadiappa
petitioner on 21.09.2016. It rejected
the petitioner‟s reliance on Hamda Ammal (supra), since the demand notice
in the present case had been issued ... DRAT rightly rejected the reliance placed by the petitioner
on Hamda Ammal (supra), keeping in view the facts of the present case.
We, therefore
submissions, learned counsel relied upon the following
judgments: -
( i) Hamda Ammal v. Avadiappa Pathar and Ors. , (1991) 1
SCC 715
( ii) Gurbax Singh v. Kartar ... first in line is the judgment of the Supreme Court in Hamda Ammal v.
Avadiappa Pathar and Ors. , this was a case where the appellant
