arises for consideration is whether Rule 5(c) disentitles petitioners to HRA.
7. Rule 5(c) relied on by the Department to deny HRA ... premises of HMT to the petitioners do not fall under Rule 5(c). HRA cannot be denied to them.
11. The Tribunal has misread Rule
make the Rules retrospective, which was not there in
their earlier Rules. However, before an employee is
14
denied HRA, the conditions stipulated in Clause ... force of these Rules. The earlier Rule was
only prospective in nature. But subsequently the said
Rules were amended by introducing Rule 11A making
HRA drawn from 1-1-1993 to
31--1--20(),2"1n viewuof R1.;Ie'"5(C}[1ii} Central Government HRA
Rules ... amount
lliseceivevdduljy respondent as HRA on the ground that
Rule 5{'c.}a(iii}'l.lof the Rules are applicable to the case
second contention of learned counsel appearing for the petitioners that Rule 3 of the Rules which prescribes the valuation of rent-free accommodation ... Central Government employees, regulations are framed as per HRA and CCA rules and in so far as the State Government employees are concerned, KCSR rules
Smt. V Chinnabai vs Mysore Urban Development Authority on 5 August, 2013
Author: Ram Mohan
Therefore, it is not open for the petitioner to claim
HRA amounts independently. Rule 5(c) of the HRA
and CCA Rules clearly reveals that ... with the benefits of HRA
as no order is passed by the respondents in favour of
the petitioner providing her HRA. In view
rent allowance
(HRA) in favour of the petitioner till 2011. Thereafter
proceedings are started against the petitioner for
recovering amounts of HRA wrongly paid ... Therefore, it is
not open for the petitioner to claim HRA amounts
independently. Rule 5(c) of the HRA and CCA Rules
clearly reveals that
The Mysore Paper Mills Limited, ... vs The Mysore Paper Mills Officers' ... on 12 August
scales prescribed under Rule 5 of the Rules 1978.
22. Though Rule 5 of the Rules 1978 provide that the scale ... PEETA, this Court was interpreting Rule 5 of Rules 1978 and it has been held that the provisions of Rule 5 would squarely apply
resignation of the petitioner.
12. Rule 4.1 of C & R Rules of the Institution
provides for adopting Rules and orders applicable to the
State ... aspect of the following matters not
specifically dealt with under these rules, the
rules and orders applicable to the State
Government employees shall apply
