Belaire Owners' Association vs Dlf Limited, Huda & Ors. Supplementary ... on 3 January, 2013
BEFORE THE
COMPETITION COMMISSION OF INDIA
CASE NO.19/2010
Huda vs Sunil Gupta on 17 September, 2012
NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES
REDRESSAL COMMISSION
NEW
DELHI
REVISION PETITION NO. 2507 of 2012
(Against
the order dated ... 1339/03 of the State
Consumer
Disputes Redressal Commission, HARYANA, PANCHKULA )
HUDA
Through its Estate Officer
Panchkula
HARYANA ..... Petitioner
Vs.
SUNIL GUPTA
sake of convenience.
2
2. The Haryana Urban Development Authority (HUDA) was constituted under
Haryana Urban Development Authority Act, 1977 . The functions of HUDA ... society; and (d) To undertake building works and other
engineering works. HUDA is developer of urban areas. It develops urban
infrastructure. It is doing business
complied with the provisions f section 194C on
payments of EDC to HUDA as the same can not be termed as payment
to contractors ... source ON the payment of external development charges to HUDA.
5. Without prejudice to the above and under the facts and
circumstances of the case
Govt. by issuing payment in the name of Haryana Urban
Development Authority (HUDA) for and on behalf of and on
instructions of Govt ... license was to pay external
development charges to Haryana Urban Development Authority
(HUDA) on the directions and on behalf of Director, Town & Country
Planning
appreciating EDC payment was made to Haryana
Urban Development Authority ('HUDA') for and on behalf of
Department of Town and Country Planning ... office of DTCP issued in the name
of the Principal Officer of HUDA was an eye wash to circumvent
the provisions of section 194C
Administrator, Haryana
Urban Development Authority, Hisar.
3.
The Estate Officer, HUDA, Sirsa.
Appellants
(Ops)
Versus
Sunita Bhatia wife of Surender
Bhatia, Resident of House ... Sector-20, HUDA Colony, Sirsa
Tehsil and District Sirsa.
Respondent (Complainant)
BEFORE:
Honble Mr. Justice R.S. Madan,
President.
Mr. B.M. Bedi, Judicial Member
Haryana State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission,
Panchkula)
1. Haryana Urban Development Authority (HUDA)
Sector
6, Panchkula
Through
its Chief Administrator
2.
Estate Officer, Haryana Urban ... Development Authority (HUDA)
Sector 14, Urban Estate, Gurgaon
Petitioners
versus
M/s
Suneja and Sons
House
no. F 115, Vikas Puri
New
Delhi
Through
before the State Commission and now before us for decision is:
If HUDA
(Haryana Urban Development Authority,
GDA (Ghaziabad Development Authority) or any other Urban ... respondent- complainant (Revision Petition No.1197/98), was
allotted on 21.2.1990 by HUDA residential plot bearing No.192 valuing
Rs.1,99,400/- in Police
under section 194C of the Act on payment
of EDC to HUDA which is highly unjustified, uncalled ... carried at the
premises of Haryana Urban Development Authority (HUDA).
During the survey proceedings, it was observed by the Revenue
Authorities that HUDA receives payment
